What Is the Best Car Insurance Comparison Site?

With car insurance rates rising and rising in the U.S., most drivers are feeling the pain in their wallets. As insurance companies hike their premiums, the best action you can take is to shop around for a better deal, and many insurance comparison platforms offer an easy service to do this for you. But which is your best option? We turned to Trustpilot to get the view on which U.S. insurance comparison site consumers rate the highest, and the rankings are in.

1. Insurify.com — 4.8 / 5 (5,967 reviews)

Insurify sits alone at the top for cheap car insurance, combining the highest score with the deepest review pool on Trustpilot—a potent signal that the experience scales beyond a handful of happy drivers. Users praise the no-spam quote flow and consistently cite real savings; independent reviewers note that Insurify surfaces prices from a huge array of national and regional carriers (over 120) without handing shoppers off to lead-gen pages. 

2. Compare.com — 4.7 / 5 (96 reviews)

Compare.com earns solid marks for a fast, side-by-side quote page and candid disclosure of how personal data is used. The Trustpilot score is based on fewer total reviews than Policygenius, yet comments consistently applaud an "easy, spam-light" process, and the site is focused on auto insurance comparison. 

3. Policygenius — 4.7 / 5 (5,917 reviews)

Originally a life-insurance marketplace, Policygenius enjoys an "Excellent" Trustpilot rating, but it is clear that a majority of these scores are for its life-insurance product. Happy shoppers highlight the option to chat with agents after completing the online quote, while negative reviews mainly mention follow-up calls from carrier partners—common among broker-style marketplaces. 

4. Gabi — 3.5 / 5 (0 reviews)

Gabi has little online chatter but is focused on auto insurance. Its policy-matching idea shows promise, but there is not much evidence of happy customers suggesting that it is popular or effective.

5. Get Jerry — 4.1 / 5 (8 reviews)

Get Jerry's Trustpilot rating trails its peers, and far fewer people have used and reviewed it. Fans like that there are some competitive rates, but other reviewers cite a long path through downloading and using an app to get teaser quotes that change dramatically after underwriting, and a long wait for final prices.

Overall, if you value the wisdom of the consumers who have trodden before you, Insurify, Compare.com, and then maybe Policygenius remain the safest first stops. Gabi and Get Jerry are also options that can be worth a look to ensure no carrier is missed, though Get Jerry requires a patient mobile shopper willing to trade speed and convenience for an app experience.