Facebook's application of "state-controlled media" tags seems to have a measurable impact on the interaction with content originating from authoritarian countries.
(Photo : STR/AFP via Getty Images)
A woman uses her mobile phone to check Facebook in Yangon on February 4,2021 as Myanmar's generals ordered internet providers to restrict access to Facebook, days after they seized power.
Recent research demonstrates that the introduction of these labels led to a notable decline in user engagement, particularly when the content was identified as coming from Chinese and Russian government-operated media outlets.
Exploring Casual Impact of State-Controlled Media Labels
A team of researchers hailing from Carnegie Mellon University, Indiana University, and the University of Texas at Austin collaborated on a study aimed at unraveling the impact of adding labels to content on Facebook. The main focus was to comprehend how these labels influenced users' desire to interact with the labeled content.
Engadget reported that the results of the study demonstrated that the presence of these labels led users to exhibit reduced engagement with the content, particularly when it originated from countries that users held in a negative light.
Conducting Three Studies
In the initial experiment, a group of 1,200 individuals possessing Facebook accounts based in the US were studied. They were exposed to posts with and without labels indicating state-controlled media. Interestingly, the reduced engagement with content from Russia and China only occurred when these individuals actively noticed the label attached to the posts.
In a subsequent phase of the study, involving 2,000 US Facebook users, the researchers uncovered a significant connection between users' behavior and the prevailing public sentiment toward the country mentioned in the label.
To elaborate, content labeled as Canadian state-controlled received a favorable response, whereas content attributed to Chinese and Russian government sources garnered a negative reaction. This underlines the intriguing phenomenon wherein these labels appear to evoke diverse reactions based on the perceived country of origin.
Lastly, a third phase of experimentation centered around assessing the extent of interaction Facebook users had with state-controlled media prior to and following the incorporation of labels by the platform. The outcomes highlighted a notable transformation in behavior.
Specifically, there was a substantial 34 percent decrease in the sharing of posts marked with labels, and user likes on tagged content experienced a significant decline of 46 percent after the introduction of these labels.
The researchers also made an interesting observation: by educating users about the presence and significance of these labels, their likelihood of noticing and recognizing them considerably increased. This underscores the pivotal role of user awareness in the effectiveness of these labels.
Also Read: Canada Urges Meta to End Ban on Domestic Online News Amid Wildfires
These studies encountered certain constraints when distinguishing between correlation and causation. The authors acknowledged their inability to definitively confirm whether the observed outcomes were directly attributed to the labels or if Facebook's opaque newsfeed algorithms, which push down labeled content, played a role.
This opacity also presents challenges for broader external research efforts. The researchers also highlighted that their experiments gauged online users' beliefs, intentions to share, and intentions to like pages, but did not delve into their concrete behavioral patterns.
The researchers, in line with the findings, suggest that social media platforms should take the proactive step of transparently notifying and educating users about any alterations in labeling policies. This should involve clarifying the significance of these labels and ensuring they are presented in a manner that captures users' attention.
In the midst of the ongoing battle against online misinformation and propaganda, the leaders of the study emphasize the need for increased efforts from Facebook and similar social platforms. Their recommendation is for these platforms to go beyond the current measures and implement further strategies to address the issue.
Related Article: Meta's Threads to Label Government-Affiliated Media Accounts
