Nintendo has taken legal steps against Yuzu, the emulator designed to run Nintendo Switch games on other platforms.
(Photo : YUICHI YAMAZAKI/AFP via Getty Images)
This picture taken on February 5, 2023 shows the logo of game giant Nintendo at a store in Tokyo. - Nintendo were expected to announce their third quarter results later on February 7.
Taking Legal Action Against Yuzu
Nintendo has initiated legal action against the developers of Yuzu in a US federal court, aiming to permanently cease the emulator's operations. While Nintendo isn't accusing Yuzu of directly stealing access keys, the lawsuit revolves around piracy concerns.
According to a lawsuit discovered by Stephen Totilo, Nintendo alleges that Yuzu violates the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) by bypassing Nintendo Switch encryption, thereby facilitating copyright infringement.
Nintendo claims that Yuzu is designed with the primary purpose of bypassing encryption barriers, enabling users to play copyrighted Nintendo games. The company is seeking more than just a halt to Yuzu's activities through a permanent injunction.
It also aims to gain control over its domain names, URLs, chatrooms, and social media accounts; transfer ownership of yuzu-emu.org to Nintendo; and even confiscate and destroy its hard drives to eradicate the emulator. Nintendo is also pursuing significant financial compensation for damages.
The legality of emulators is a nuanced topic. Past legal cases suggest that creating an emulator by reverse engineering a console without using the source code might be acceptable, but these rulings are outdated, spanning back twenty-five years or more.
However, the situation becomes more complex when modern encryption layers and copyrighted BIOSes, crucial for emulators like Yuzu, are taken into account.
Also Read: Dolphin, Nintendo GameCube Emulator, Coming to Steam Later This Year-What to Expect?
The Dolphin Emulator, designed for Nintendo Wii and GameCube, faced scrutiny over its plans to launch on Steam. Concerns arose when it was discovered that Dolphin ships with Nintendo's Wii common key, a component used to bypass copyright protection on Wii games.
However, Nintendo's legal action against Yuzu takes a different route. Unlike Dolphin, Yuzu does not include such keys. Instead, it adopts a "bring-your-own-BIOS" approach, where users are required to procure their BIOSes and keys, often obtained from hacked Nintendo Switch consoles or pirated sources.
Nintendo's primary argument against Yuzu revolves around its alleged facilitation of piracy on a massive scale. While the emulator does not directly provide copyrighted keys, Nintendo contends that its existence enables users to engage in widespread piracy.
Nintendo has raised concerns over the Yuzu emulator, suggesting that it plays a significant role in facilitating piracy through various means.
Yuzu allegedly provides detailed instructions on how to run unlawfully obtained copies of Nintendo Switch games and has extensively tested thousands of official Nintendo Switch titles to ensure compatibility.
Nintendo also accuses the developers of Yuzu of linking to websites that aid users in acquiring and distributing copyrighted keys. Furthermore, the company asserts that the developers of Yuzu have extracted Switch games themselves, bypassing encryption measures, to test their emulator.
What Will Happen?
If Nintendo can demonstrate that Yuzu is primarily intended for granting access to official Nintendo Switch games without any other legitimate purpose, the emulator may face legal repercussions.
Under DMCA Section 1201(a)(2), products primarily designed to circumvent technological measures controlling access to copyrighted works are prohibited, posing a challenge that game archivists have grappled with for years.
Related Article: Nintendo Switch 2 Delayed to March 2025 - What We Know So Far
