Vodafone's CEO Advocates for Regulatory Reform and Industry-Wide Collaboration The UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) launched a probe into Vodafone and Three UK's planned merger that may affect consumer costs and infrastructure quality in mobile telecommunications.
The CMA is concerned about the merger, which would combine two of the UK's four largest mobile network carriers and change market dynamics. The merger would be the UK's biggest mobile phone provider with 27 million users and would overtake market leaders EE, owned by BT, and Virgin Media O2, owned by Telefónica and Liberty Global, according to a report from The Guardian.
After a phase 1 inquiry, the CMA voiced concerns about the merger's effect on competition and consumer welfare. The regulator expressed concern about higher mobile service charges and less investment in UK mobile networks. The CMA also stressed the significance of sector competition for consumer benefit.
Vodafone and Three UK's assertions of competition and investment benefits were unsupported by evidence, according to CMA phase 1 decision-maker Julie Bon. Thus, the CMA has given firms five days to suggest remedies to these issues. If replies are not sufficient within this period, phase 2 research may last 24 weeks.
(Photo : ADRIAN DENNIS/AFP via Getty Images)
A pedestrian walks past a Vodafone store in central London on May 16, 2023.
Vodafone and Three UK expressed confidence in their proposed transaction's capacity to improve competition, serve consumers, and promote the UK in a joint statement.
Companies highlighted the poor performance of their mobile networks in the United Kingdom compared to other European countries. They claimed to be "sub-scale," unable to pay capital expenditures, and lacking investment and competitive skills compared to market giants like EE and Virgin Media O2.
Merger to Benefit Consumers Claim Vodafone, Three
Ahmed Essam, Vodafone UK's chief executive, stressed that the acquisition will enable the merged business to confront market incumbents like BT and VMO2. He said the transaction will benefit consumers, competition, and the country by giving mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) more wholesale market alternatives, as reported by CNBC.
Read Also: Apple's 'Walled-Garden' Approach Targeted in New US Antitrust Lawsuit
Three UK CEO Robert Finnegan shared Essam's concerns about the market structure's negative effects on customers and competition. He stressed that by merging, the companies will create a powerful third player with the scale to attract significant investment. Finnegan wanted to build one of Europe's most sophisticated networks to put the UK at the forefront of digital and benefit customers.
The firms' statements emphasize using the combination to solve industry problems, improve network capabilities, and prepare the UK for digital transformation.
Small Players May Suffer
A formal probe was launched nine months after the $19 billion merger transaction was announced. Vodafone and Three UK want to complete the deal by 2024 despite regulatory issues. The CMA's phase 1 market examination sought stakeholder input before deciding on further inquiry, according to a TechCrunch report.
Aside from the on the possible loss in competition stemming from the Vodafone-Three merger, authorities are concerned about its impact on smaller mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) who depend on favorable wholesale arrangements to deliver competitive services.
Three UK's ownership by Hong Kong firm CK Hutchison Holdings raises national security concerns. Although beyond the CMA's authority, both corporations are apparently collaborating with government assessments under the 2022 National Security and Investment Act.
Related Article: MWC 2024: Vodafone's CEO Advocates for Regulatory Reform and Industry-Wide Collaboration
